Oliver North sought a second term as president of the National Rifle Association.
It was not to be.
NRA first Vice President Richard Childress read a note from North aloud to thousands of the gun groups members at their annual convention in Indianapolis. It relayed news of the retired lieutenant colonels departure and raised the specter of an existential threat to the organization.
As North had put it in a letter to the NRA board: I am deeply concerned that these allegations of financial improprieties could threaten our nonprofit status.
Could they? And what did North mean when he expressed concern about the NRAs nonprofit status?
Im an attorney who has worked for the Internal Revenue Service on legal matters associated with tax-exempt organizations and a professor who studies nonprofit law. It strikes me as unlikely that the IRS would strip the NRA of its tax-exempt status.
At the same time, I think its possible that the New York authorities investigating the group might remove officers and members of its 76-member board of directors. There is even a slight possibility, as NRA CEO Wayne LaPierre warned in a fundraising letter, that New York authorities could cause the NRA to shut down forever. But I doubt it.
The NRA and the IRS
The NRA consists of multiple kinds of entities, including a political action committee and four affiliated charities.
But its mainstay, which North led until this leadership showdown, is whats known as a social welfare organization under section 501(c)(4) of the tax code.
There is no charitable contribution deduction for paying NRA membership dues or donating to the social welfare organization.
What does tax-exemption do for the NRA then? Just like a charity, it generally doesnt pay taxes on the money it raises or earns.
In exchange for that special status, the NRA must benefit the public according to a very broad definition. Advocacy and education, including about gun safety and gun ownership qualifies. The NRA must also submit mandatory paperwork to the IRS every year.
There are a few things the NRA cant do as a nonprofit, too. It cant primarily benefit private individuals through excessive compensation or companies rather than the public. It cant make engaging in politics its main purpose. And it cant break laws, including campaign finance laws.
Retaining tax-exempt status
Norths vague allegations could point to two primary matters that could run afoul of federal tax law.
First, instead of being run to advance NRA missions like to defend and foster the Second Amendment rights of all law-abiding Americans, he asserts that the group mainly enriches NRA executives and boosts the bottom line of Ackerman McQueen, an advertising company that runs the NRA TV video channel. The second is admittedly odd given that North was paid by Ackerman McQueen through a contractual relationship.
Second, perhaps North is raising concerns related to media reports of allegations that the NRA illegally funneled millions of dollars in Russian money to Donald Trumps 2016 presidential campaign.
In the first instance, the IRS or the Tax Court a forum that decides disputes between taxpayers and the IRS could theoretically determine that the NRA overcompensated Ackerman McQueen or any of the groups top officials. In that case, the group or its officials might have to pay fines known as excise taxes for having received improper benefits or knowingly wasted or misdirected money.
In the second, the IRS could theoretically determine the NRA was operated for an illegal purpose and revoke its tax exempt status. But, more likely, the IRS would seek assurances from the NRA to take appropriate corrective actions to ensure it doesnt serve as a conduit for foreign campaign cash again.
New York probe
The NRA is headquartered in Northern Virginia but it has been incorporated as a charitable nonprofit in New York state since 1871. That empowers the states authorities to oversee its operations.
Its attorney general can remove nonprofit officers and directors found to have failed to ensure that their organizations follow the rules and behave in a financially sound manner. The states attorney general can even shut down nonprofits that operate for improper or illegal purposes.
The IRS hasnt indicated that its investigating the NRA. But New York Attorney General Letitia James has said her office is without disclosing any details. While campaigning for her office in 2018, James vowed to scrutinize the gun group, saying I will use the constitutional power as an attorney general to regulate charities, that includes the NRA, to investigate their legitimacy.
The NRA subsequently audited its contractors. When Ackerman McQueen failed to hand over all records requested, the NRA sued. The most prominent similar nonprofit probe to date scrutinized the Trump Foundation. Its being dissolved following a settlement with Jamess predecessor.
You might be wondering why the NRA hasnt reincorporated in another state. While it could, that would be costly and complicated. Similarly, should the IRS ever question the NRAs tax-exempt status, the NRA might choose to let it go, like the National Football League did in 2015.
Even when nonprofit regulatory authorities detect improprieties, they try to avoid shuttering tax-exempt organizations. They recognize that most people who belong to and support those groups had nothing to do with the wrongdoing. Where possible, they punish wrongdoers without jeopardizing a nonprofits viability.